For my second project I
want to analyze the story Ramona, written by Helen Hunt Jackson. Which
topic to choose will be the hard part. I feel the reading has so much to
offer.
1. Reflecting on
its historical, social, political and/or economic context; focusing on race,
class, power, cultural values and beliefs, historical events, the author's
biography, gender, psychology, etc.
Ramona is a story of an unlikely romance between a Spanish
raised girl and Indian boy and is written as a social protest. The small
excerpt of this story only shows a quick glimpse of the whole story. To make
the most out of my project, I would like to read the full novel to address each
context mentioned above. There is so much to be said about race, class, power,
and cultural values and beliefs within this story.
2. How are class
differences presented in the work? Are characters aware or unaware of the
economic and social forces that affect their lives?
Again,
for this topic, I feel like I would need to read the full novel to be able to
effectively write about the main characters who are mentioned in the excerpt. Throughout
the story, Ramona and Alessandro fight for everything and after they seemingly
have won, it is all taken away because of their ethnic and social standing. The whole story is written about class differences and the impact of economic and social forces.
3.
Still choosing the reading Ramona:
Choose one short
story or novel excerpt. Write a piece in which you explore the following:
1. In what ways could this story
be considered an artifact of history?
The
author, Helen Hunt Jackson was an activist and wrote the story of Ramona and
Alessandro with the hope to bring awareness to the treatment towards American
Indians. Because this story was written during the height of this disturbing
time in our American history, it references very real and plausible
situations.
2. What does this story teach us
about history? The story teaches us history
from a different perspective. My generation might read about history or be
taught about history, but we are so removed from these terrible things that it
is hard to fathom the reality. Stories like this bring that reality to
life.
3. How does a story teach us
about a time or place differently than a history book? Similar to question 2, history books
reference time periods as a generalization. It is hard to personalize
everything about history. History books also often tell the story from one
point of view. This story brings a few different points of view to light.
Hi Amanda,
ReplyDeleteI like that you are looking at one story that you enjoyed reading and choosing topics around it. I think your first two choices would be difficult because you said that you would need to read the whole novel and due to the limited time we have, I don't know how difficult or achievable that would be for you.
I think you have a great start for your third choice and I think you will have enough in the passage in our book to complete your project. You will also be able to do some research about the author and period in time that it is written to give you additional supporting evidence. You can also identify the different views that the story brings into light.
Honestly, I do not remember this story and would have to go back and read it. I can tell this will be a great project with a lot of information, I will come back and read it. Good luck.
Thank you, Amber, you are probably right! I can't even keep up with required readings, I would never be able to actually read a full novel! Thank you for your constructive feedback! You are appreciated :)
ReplyDeleteHi again, Amanda!
ReplyDeleteWow I love that you have the reading you want to work with already in mind. Also, it seems that, even though you haven't decided yet which one to pick, you have everything planned out. What is awesome! I really enjoyed reading your brainstorm because your ideas are really clear and you're pretty much sure of how to develop your project.
I haven't read this one, though, and I don't know what it is about except what you mentioned about a romance between a Spanish girl and an Indian boy. I saw the time that this story takes place, so I assume that race and social segregation are the major themes here. Since I don't know the story, I don't think I have the right to suggest something either, but I would still suggest the 1st topic. As you mentioned the story seems to offer lots of things related to those major issues and I'd love to read your final result on that.
But the final decision is yours, of course. However, it'll sure be another amazing project!